Bone Marrow Transplant clinical outcomes

Clinical outcomes are measurable changes in health, function or quality of life that result from our care. Constant review of our clinical outcomes establishes standards against which to continuously improve all aspects of our practice.

About the Bone Marrow Transplant Service

The Bone Marrow Transplant (BMT) Unit runs a comprehensive stem cell transplant (SCT) service for children with life-threatening diseases.

These include:

  • leukaemia
  • solid tumours
  • bone marrow failure
  • immunodeficiency diseases
  • inherited metabolic disorders
  • autoimmune or immune dysregulatory diseases

The BMT Unit is the largest paediatric BMT centre in the UK and now performs approximately 90 transplant procedures every year.

Clinical outcome measures

We measure our transplant outcomes in a range of ways including survival for all conditions treated, survival by groups of similar conditions, and complications of treatment.

1. Overall patient survival for allograft transplant

‘Overall survival’ is a measure of survival, whether the patient is free from the disease or not.

An allograft is a transplant of an organ, tissue or cells from one person to another where donor and recipient’s genotypes are different (ie not an identical twin). This measure shows survival in all patients who underwent an allograft transplant. Types of conditions treated include immunodeficiencies, metabolic conditions, gastrointestinal conditions, malignant and non-malignant conditions of the blood, cancers and rheumatic conditions.

Definition: Rate/percentage of patients alive at one year after allograft.

Table 1.1 Patients survival one year after allograft by year, 2013 to 2021

Year Overall patient survival for allograft transplant
2013 48/64 (75%)
2014 68/79 (86%)
2015 52/70 (74%)
2016 46/58 (79%)
2017 49/57 (85%)
2018 48/61 (79%)
2019 58/64 (91%)
2020 50/60 (83%)
2021 61/65 (94%)

It is important to note that overall survival rates can be influenced by all mortality and is not just related to transplant mortality. For example, if a patient died for a reason unrelated to their health condition, this would be counted.

2. Overall patient survival for allograft transplant – malignancies only

‘Overall survival’ is a measure of survival, whether the patient is free from the disease or not.

This measure shows overall survival rates for patients treated with stem cell transplantation for malignancies, including acute lymphoblastic leukaemia, acute myeloid leukaemia, chronic myeloid leukaemia, juvenile myelomonocytic leukaemia, myelodysplastic syndromes, and non-hodgkin lymphoma.

Malignancies have the lowest overall survival rate of all conditions treated by stem cell transplantation because children who have been pre-treated with a lot of chemotherapy, can experience more toxicity during SCT. Ongoing clinical research seeks to learn more about how to treat these conditions to improve survival rates.

Definition: Rate/percentage of patients alive at one year after allograft to treat malignancies.

Table 2.1 patients survival one year after allograft to treat malignancies by year, 2013 to 2021

Year Overall survival rate atone year for malignancies
2013 11/19 (57%)
2014 20/27 (74%)
2015 10/21 (47%)
2016 15/20 (75%)
2017 23/29 (79%)
2018 22/30 (73%)
2019 23/28 (82%)
2020 23/27 (85%)
2021 15/19 (79%)

3. Disease-free patient survival for allograft transplant – malignancies only

Disease-free survival’ is a measure of survival, counting only those patients who are alive and free from the disease they received treatment for.

This measure shows disease-free survival rates for patients treated with stem cell transplantation for malignancies, including acute lymphoblastic leukaemia, acute myeloid leukaemia, chronic myeloid leukaemia, juvenile myelomonocytic leukaemia, myelodysplastic syndromes, and non-hodgkin lymphoma.

Malignancies have the lowest disease-free survival rate of all conditions treated by stem cell transplantation because sometimes malignancies can relapse (recur) despite a successful transplant. Ongoing clinical research seeks to learn more about how to treat these conditions to improve survival rates.

Definition: Rate/percentage of patients alive and disease-free at one year after allograft to treat malignancies.

Table 3.1 Patients alive and disease-free at one year after allograft to treat malignancies by year,
2013 to 2021

Year Disease-free survival rate at one year for malignancies
2013 11/19 (57%)
2014 18/27 (67%)
2015 9/21 (43%)
2016 9/20 (45%)
2017 18/29 (62%)
2018 21/30 (70%)
2019 20/28 (71%)
2020 21/27 (78%)
2021 12/19 (63%)

4. Grade 3 and 4 GvHD

Graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) is the most common complication following SCT from a related or unrelated donor. When GvHD occurs, the immune cells (called T-cells) of the donor attack new cells in the transplant recipient’s body causing a skin rash (attack on skin), diarrhoea and vomiting (attack on the gut, or jaundice (attack on the liver).

GVHD is graded according to its severity. Grade 3 and 4 are the most severe grades. Morbidity (ill health) and mortality (death) is higher in grades 3 and 4 GVHD.

Definition: Number/percentage of patients who had grade 3 or 4 GvHD, who had a day 0 (ie transplant start) from prior calendar year when data collected for January audit.

Table 4.1 Patients who had grade 3 or 4 GvHD by year, 2013 to 2021

Year Patients who had aGrade 3 or 4 GvHD
2013 <5 / 64 (<10%)
2014 5/79 (6%)
2015 7/70 (10%)
2016 <5 / 58 (<10%)
2017 8/57 (14%)
2018 11/61 (18%)
2019 <5 / 64 (<10%)
2020 6/60 (10%)
2021 3/65 (5%)

To prevent the identification of individual patients, where there are low numbers of patients ie fewer than five, exact numbers are not shown.

Based on international publications, rates of up to 10% grade 3 and 4 GvHD may be expected following unrelated donor transplants.

This information was updated in November 2022.