[Skip to content]

.

Controversies about childhood development

24 September 2008

In the last half a century, the orthodoxy about the long term impact of childhood on adult development has swung too and fro.   Professor Michael Rutter will deliver the Great Ormond Street Lecture [5.15pm, Weds 24th Sept] on what half a century of science now tells us.

Drawing on the latest research in genetics and neurology, he discounts three once fashionable and contradictory views

-that the first three years of life uniquely determines the rest of life

-that early experience doesn’t matter very much

-that only extreme experiences in early years matters

The brain does develop rapidly in the first three years; there are some windows which can be missed; but for many things development runs into adulthood (with adolescence another area of rapid development).  Good early years helps set the course but shortfalls can often be mitigated.

Psychological health depends on developing coping mechanisms.  Just as the immune system develops by meeting immune challenges, so we need to help children cope, rather than hope to avoid all stress and anxiety.

Resilience is an enormously interesting area.  It appears some children with the right genes are very resilient to deal with certain challenges, others who live in an environment without those challenges will also avoid problems, whatever their genes. 

Experience can alter our brains – as the research showing taxi drivers have a larger hippocampus, that part of the brain which deals with memorising routes and journeys.

Children affect their parents as well as vice versa:  Studies have shown for example that some adoptive parents behave differently to adoptive children whose biological families have certain issues, compared to those adoptive children who do not.  In other words, the children are cueing certain types of behaviour in the adults.

Professor Rutter said: “The lessons need to pull together the various different issues that have been considered.  Thus, the quality of children’s rearing environment really matters and committed family relationships are particularly important.  Family, peer group, school and community are all influential but they are all interconnected.  That is, it is not just what parents do in bringing up children within the family home but it is also through their choices that influence peer groups, schooling and community.”

“The quality of family relationships is more important than family structure.  There has been a tendency to focus on the risks associated with being brought up by a single parent.  It is true that there are risks but they are very dependent on the implications for the quality of rearing.  It is not whether or not there are one or two parents that is crucial but rather that parenting is more difficult if one parent has to do it on their own.“

The lecture is public and free. 

Contact information:

GOSH-ICH Press Office: 020 7239 3125
Email: Coxs@gosh.nhs.uk
For genuine and urgent out of hours call speak to switchboard on 020 7405 9200

Notes to editors

Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children NHS Trust is the country’s leading centre for treating sick children, with the widest range of specialists under one roof.

With the UCL Institute of Child Health, we are the largest centre for paediatric research outside the US and play a key role in training children’s health specialists for the future.

Our charity needs to raise £50 million every year to help rebuild and refurbish Great Ormond Street Hospital, buy vital equipment and fund pioneering research. With your help we provide world class care to our very ill children and their families.